J's Dumpster Rentals
Home/Blog/How Dumpster Overage Billing Works

How Dumpster Overage Billing Works

By Jeff Hensley · August 22, 2026 · Pricing

Overage billing at J's applies to four materials and works from one figure, the weight on the landfill's scale ticket. Concrete, dirt, shingles, and plaster and lath are billed by weight: the rental includes the first 1,000 pounds, and each ton past that costs $50. Every other load, from furniture to drywall to carpet, goes at the flat rate on the Richmond dumpster price list, with no weight charge at all. Jeff explains the weight rule on the phone before delivery, so a customer of Jeff's Richmond roll off dumpster rental knows how a heavy load is billed before it goes in.

Which loads get an overage charge?

Only loads with concrete, dirt, shingles, or plaster and lath in them. Household contents, furniture, mattresses, cabinets, drywall, carpet, lumber and yard debris all go at the flat rate, whatever they weigh. A 16-yard of furniture and a 16-yard of drywall cost the same.

The four heavy materials go in the 12-yard dumpster only. Jeff doesn't put them in the 16-yard, because of the weight. The rental price on the heavy 12-yard is the same $295, $325 or $375 as a standard 12-yard, and the weight past the first 1,000 pounds is the only addition.

Brick, block and tile aren't among the four. Ask Jeff how he bills brick, block or tile.

How is the overage worked out?

Subtract 1,000 pounds from the weight on the scale ticket, divide what's left by 2,000 to get tons, and multiply by $50. A ton is 2,000 pounds, so the included 1,000 pounds is half a ton of heavy material.

For example:

  • A load that weighs 900 pounds is under the included weight, so there's no overage.
  • A load that weighs 3,000 pounds is 2,000 pounds over, or one ton, so the overage is $50.
  • A load that weighs 5,000 pounds is 4,000 pounds over, or two tons, so the overage is $100.

Add the overage to the rental price for the days you booked. On a 3-day rental at $325, the 5,000-pound load comes to $425 in all. There's no sales tax on a dumpster rental, so nothing else goes on top. If the weight past 1,000 pounds includes a partial ton, ask Jeff how it's billed.

Where does the weight come from?

The weight comes from the landfill on New Paris Pike in Richmond, on the Indiana side of the state line. Jeff hauls the full dumpster there, the load is weighed at the scale house, and the weight past 1,000 lb comes off that scale ticket.

The city of Richmond runs the landfill. Richmond runs its trash utility through the Richmond Sanitary District, and the New Paris Pike landfill has been in operation since 1968, per the Richmond Sanitary District. Jeff's yard on South H Street and the landfill are both inside Richmond.

Does the rental length change the overage?

No. The 1,000 pounds included and the $50 a ton past that are the same on a 1-day, 3-day or 7-day rental. Only the rental price changes with the days. A roof crew on a one-day rental and a homeowner breaking out a patio over a week get the same weight rule.

Is the overage the same in Eaton and New Paris?

Yes. Eaton and New Paris are priced from the same table as Richmond, and the heavy rule is the same: the 12-yard only, the first 1,000 pounds included, then $50 a ton. Eaton is 17 road miles from Jeff's yard and New Paris is 8, and delivery and pickup are included in both towns with nothing added for the distance.

Does a full dumpster of household debris cost more?

No. A household or remodel load with none of the four heavy materials costs the flat rate whether it goes back half full or full. The size and the days you book set the price, and the amount inside doesn't change it.

How does Jeff explain the weight rule before delivery?

Jeff asks what the project is on every call. In his words: "I ask all of my customers, what's your project?" If the answer is a roof, a patio, a dirt job or an old house with plaster walls, he talks through the weight rule with you before the dumpster is delivered.

He screens heavy jobs at the start of the call. In his words: "after I got wise to everything, I'm pretty good about screening it up front." On what goes in, he lays out the rules at the start too: "I always kind of lay it out to them."

For a roof, tell him the squares and the layers. For concrete, give him the length and width of the slab or walk. For plaster, tell him how many rooms are coming down to the studs. The roof tear-off guide explains how to read the squares off a roofer's estimate, and the concrete guide prices a sidewalk and a patio at the same rates.

What if a load mixes heavy material with other debris?

Describe everything going in, and Jeff will tell you how the load is billed. A kitchen remodel with drywall and cabinets and no heavy material goes at the flat rate. A remodel that opens up plaster walls, or a roof job with old decking coming off along with the shingles, should be described to Jeff before you book.

For a dirt job, say whether it's loose soil, sod or fill. For a cleanout, mention anything unusual in the garage or basement, such as an old concrete laundry tub or a few bundles of leftover shingles, so Jeff can tell you up front how each part is billed.

Who rents a dumpster for heavy loads?

The heavy material dumpster is for anyone whose load includes one of the four materials: roofing contractors with shingle tear-offs, general contractors, and homeowners with a patio or an old plaster wall coming out. A shingle tear-off goes on the roofing dumpster rental prices, which are the same 12-yard rates of $295, $325 and $375 plus the weight past 1,000 pounds.

Call Jeff at (765) 238-1393, tell him what's going in, and he'll explain how the load is billed.

Rent a Dumpster in Richmond

12 and 16 yard roll-offs at published prices, from Jeff's yard in Richmond. Call to schedule: (765) 238-1393.

Keep Reading

Rent a Dumpster Around Richmond

Questions? Call or text Jeff.

Call Now