Pick the 12-yard if any of the load is heavy material or the job is one room or a garage, and pick the 16-yard for bigger loads of lighter debris, like a full-house cleanout. Both dumpsters from J's are 12 feet long and 6 feet wide. The 12-yard has 43-inch walls, about waist height, and the 16-yard has 61-inch walls. So the choice depends on what's going in and how much of it there is. Jeff has done over 2,000 rentals since he opened J's Richmond dumpster rentals in January 2022, and he'll name the size on the phone once you describe the job.
How are the 12-yard and 16-yard dumpsters different?
Both have the same 12 by 6 foot floor, and the 16-yard's walls are 18 inches taller, which gives it about a third more room.
The 16-yard dumpster costs $30 more than the 12-yard for one day and $50 more for three or seven days. The 12-yard starts at $295 and the 16-yard at $325, with delivery, pickup and the dump fee in both prices. The Richmond dumpster cost guide prices out a cleanout, a remodel and a patio tear-out at those rates.
Since the footprint is the same, the 16-yard needs no more room on your driveway than the 12-yard. Jeff places dumpsters on your property, and a spot that fits one size fits the other. Janneice, one of his Google reviewers, wrote, "I have a long wooded driveway and they were still able to accommodate me." If the street is the only spot you have, the dumpster permit page explains calling the city first.
When does the load have to go in the 12-yard?
Any load with concrete, dirt, shingles, or plaster and lath goes in the 12-yard dumpster. Jeff doesn't put those four materials in the 16-yard, because of the weight. In his words: "I only use the 12 yards for the heavy stuff. I don't use the 16s."
That means a roof tear-off, a patio or sidewalk coming out, a load of dirt, or a room of old plaster walls going to the studs all go in the 12-yard. The heavy material dumpster is the same price as a standard 12-yard, with 1,000 pounds included and $50 a ton past that, taken off the landfill's scale ticket.
Brick, block and tile aren't on Jeff's heavy list. Ask Jeff how he bills brick, block or tile before you pick a size for them.
Which jobs fit the 16-yard dumpster?
The 16-yard fits bigger loads of lighter debris: furniture, mattresses, cabinets, drywall, carpet and household contents. For clearing a full house, the 16-yard gives you the extra room, and a large house can need more than one. A kitchen remodel with the cabinets and drywall coming out, or a barn cleanout, is also a good fit for the 16-yard.
Furniture and household goods are bulky for their weight. Once a sofa, a mattress and a couple of dressers are in, much of the floor is used. The 16-yard's taller walls hold more of it on the same footprint.
An estate cleanout is a 16-yard job for the same reason. Jeff has handled several estate cleanouts in Cambridge City, 15 miles west of Richmond on US 40.
Which jobs fit the 12-yard dumpster?
The 12-yard fits one room, a garage, a smaller weekend project, and jobs where heavy pieces get lifted in by hand. A garage of old tools, shelving and yard equipment, a single bedroom being emptied, or a spare room being cleared for a remodel all fit the 12-yard's floor.
The lower walls also make loading easier. If you're carrying heavy, awkward items out of a basement all afternoon, lifting each one to 43 inches takes less effort than lifting it to 61 inches.
A bathroom tear-out can go either way. Tell Jeff what's coming out and he'll pick the size.
Do long items fit in both sizes?
Yes. Both dumpsters have the same 12-foot-long floor, so a door, a section of fence, a rolled carpet or a length of lumber shorter than the dumpster's 12-foot length lies flat in either one. Laying long pieces flat on the floor first leaves the rest of the space for bulky items.
The 6-foot width is the same on both as well. A sofa or a mattress laid flat on the floor fits the 12-yard as well as the 16-yard, so the size choice depends on how much else is going in on top.
Does it cost more to fill the 16-yard to the top?
No. A normal load is a flat rate on either size, so the price depends on the size and days you book, never on how full the dumpster is. Both sizes come in the same 1, 3 and 7-day rental lengths, and the pricing page lists all six prices side by side.
Weight charges apply only to the four heavy materials, and those go in the 12-yard. A 16-yard of furniture and drywall costs the same whether it goes back half full or full.
What if you aren't sure which size you need?
Call Jeff and describe the job, and he'll name the size. Telling him how many pickup-truck loads you expect, or which rooms you're clearing, gives him what he needs. He asks every caller what the project is before he books anything, so the size question gets settled on that call. On a household job that's close to the line, mention the largest pieces, such as a sectional sofa, a piano or a hot tub, and he'll pick the size from there.
Jeff has no preference between the two sizes and books the one that fits the job. Jeremy, one of his reviewers, wrote that Jeff "didnt try to upsale." If you'd like to read before you call, the size guide has a project picker that suggests a size for a barn cleanout, an estate cleanout and other jobs.
To settle the size, call Jeff at (765) 238-1393 and tell him what's going in.
Rent a Dumpster in Richmond
12 and 16 yard roll-offs at published prices, from Jeff's yard in Richmond. Call to schedule: (765) 238-1393.
